Located at 905 Church Ave in the heart of Brooklyn, New York, Wheated has established itself as a distinctive destination for those who appreciate the intersection of traditional craftsmanship and local community spirit. The restaurant serves as a gathering place where the focus remains firmly on quality ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and a welcoming atmosphere that reflects the character of its neighborhood. For residents and visitors alike, stepping into Wheated offers a reprieve from the fast-paced nature of city life, inviting guests to slow down and enjoy a meal prepared with genuine care.
The philosophy behind Wheated is rooted in the belief that food should be approachable yet exceptional. By prioritizing the sourcing of high-quality components, the kitchen team ensures that every dish maintains a consistent standard of excellence. This commitment to quality is evident in the textures and flavors that define their menu, creating a dining experience that feels both familiar and refined. Whether you are stopping by for a casual evening meal or celebrating a special occasion with friends, the environment is designed to foster conversation and connection, making it a staple of the Church Avenue corridor.
Key Highlights of the Wheated Experience
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: The kitchen places a significant emphasis on selecting premium, locally sourced, and seasonal ingredients. By focusing on the integrity of the raw materials, the culinary team is able to highlight natural flavors, ensuring that every bite is balanced and satisfying.
A Welcoming Neighborhood Atmosphere: Situated in Brooklyn, the restaurant prides itself on being an inclusive space. The interior design and service style are curated to make every guest feel at home, bridging the gap between a sophisticated dining establishment and a comfortable local hangout.
Artisanal Craftsmanship: There is a clear dedication to the process of preparation. From the handling of dough to the precise timing required for perfect cooking, the staff demonstrates a deep respect for culinary techniques that honor tradition while remaining relevant to modern tastes.
Community-Centric Philosophy: Beyond the food, Wheated functions as a vital part of the local ecosystem. By engaging with the community and maintaining a consistent presence on Church Avenue, the restaurant contributes to the vibrant cultural fabric of the area, serving as a reliable anchor for neighborhood dining.
The attention to detail at Wheated extends beyond the plate, influencing every aspect of the guest experience. From the moment you enter the space, the warmth of the service team and the carefully considered layout of the dining room work in harmony to create a memorable visit. It is this holistic approach—balancing culinary skill with hospitality—that has allowed the restaurant to build a loyal following. The team understands that a great meal is not just about the food itself, but about the environment in which it is shared and the people who make the experience possible.
As the culinary landscape of Brooklyn continues to evolve, Wheated remains steadfast in its mission to provide honest, high-quality food. The restaurant avoids the temptation of fleeting trends, choosing instead to focus on the elements that truly matter: consistency, flavor, and community. This dedication to their craft ensures that guests can always expect a reliable and enjoyable experience, regardless of how often they visit. For those navigating the diverse food scene of New York City, finding a place that feels this authentic is a rare and rewarding discovery.
Whether you are a long-time resident of the neighborhood or simply passing through Brooklyn, a visit to 905 Church Ave offers a unique perspective on local dining. The combination of a relaxed setting, a focus on quality, and a genuine passion for hospitality makes Wheated a noteworthy stop. We invite you to experience the thoughtful approach to cooking that defines this Brooklyn establishment and to enjoy a meal that celebrates the simple pleasure of good food shared in good company.
Final Thoughts on Your Visit
Wheated stands as a testament to the idea that a restaurant can be both a pillar of its community and a destination for food lovers. By maintaining a clear vision and a dedication to quality, the establishment continues to provide a meaningful dining experience for all who walk through its doors. We encourage you to visit and see for yourself why this location has become a cherished part of the Church Avenue community, offering a blend of tradition and quality that is increasingly hard to find in the modern dining world.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Service options
Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great wine list
Popular for
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining options
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar onsite
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy
Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Parking
Free street parking
Paid street parking
Menus
Pizza Menu
Mixed Greens$9.00
Caesar Salad**$9.00
Summer Salad$8.00
Ditmas Park$10.00
Park Slope$13.00
Kensington*$13.00
Brooklyn Heights*
Gravesend*$13.00
Bensonhurst$13.00
Caton Park*$14.00
Borough Park*$14.00
Vinegar Hill*$14.00
Red Hook*$15.00
Brighton Beach*$15.00
Coney Island 2.0$15.00
Sunset Park$15.00
East Williamsburg*$15.00
Clinton Hill$15.00
Fort Greene*$14.00
Bay Ridge$13.00
Manhattan Beach*$13.00
Windsor Terrace*$16.00
Tomato Sauce$1.00
Roasted Onions$1.00
Fresh Spicy Jalapenos$1.00
Drink Menu
Seelbach$10.00
Bourbon Manhattan$9.00
Horses Neck$9.00
Bourbon Smash$9.00
New York Sour$9.00
Mint Julep$9.00
Blood and Sand$10.00
Penicillin$10.00
French 75$10.00
Negroni$10.00
Gin & Tonic$9.00
Pimm's Cup$10.00
Moscow Mule$9.00
Cuba Libre$9.00
Bitter Mai Tai$10.00
Capirinha$8.00
Paloma$9.00
Margarita$9.00
Mezcal Cup$10.00
Blanco Old Fashioned$10.00
Bordeaux, La Fleur Du Roi
Vitiano Umbria, Falesco
Chianti Cetamura, Badia A Coltobuono
Primo Nero, Li Veli
Valpolicella DOC, Zenato
Albarino, Condes de Albarei
Chenin Blanc + Viognier, Pine Ridge
Viognier, Yalumba Y Serie
Reisling, Clean Slate
inot Grigio, St. Michael Eppan
Le Rosé di Regaleali Sicilia, Tasca D'Alerita
Le Petit Gueissard, Les Vignobles Guiessard
Cuvee Brut Vino, Zardetto Private
House Ginger and Lime$3.00
House White Cola$3.00
Sprecher Root Beer$4.00
Sprecher Cream Soda$4.00
Sprecher Orange Cream Soda$4.00
Mexican Coke$3.00
Diet Coke$1.50
Photos
Reviews Wheated
Andrew Dabydeen
30-05-2026
Wheated probably takes the crown for some of the best specialty pizzas in Brooklyn. We absolutely loved our dinner here. The space has a fast, lively energy that makes it feel like you’re in on a neighborhood favorite, and the food … More
lee Vogel
30-05-2026
Definitely one of the TOP Pie spots in Brooklyn!
Love the aesthetics! The bathroom door blending into the wall is cool! I don’t … More
Dwight Kenneth
30-05-2026
First Impressions & Vibe:
We popped in on a Saturday with no reservation and were seated within 10 … More
Josh Spare
30-05-2026
I just moved over to the Flatbush area from the city and I was looking for a solid local pizza spot you can dine it at. This is the one! Been twice and both times the pizza was phenomenal (top 10 in all of NYC good). The atmosphere and … More
Lourdes Echagarruga
30-05-2026
We popped in and it was busy. Luckily they had 3 seats at the bar. 10/10 would recommend. We got 2 12" pizzas and it was perfect for 3 people. We took home a few slices. Both pizzas were delicious. … More
Andrea Posada Colavizza
30-05-2026
Amazing pizza! Despite we had to wait over 1 hour, the service was good and the pizza was so delicious, that i would definitely come back!!! More
Brooklyn PC
30-05-2026
From the moment we walked in, we knew this would be something special. The pizzas were absolutely phenomenal. The arugula pie was fresh and perfectly balanced, the classic Margherita was full of bold flavor, and the meatballs? Out of this … More
Scott Miranda
30-05-2026
My son is GF so he ate before I did here. Came just after 5 so the dining area was packed! … More
Areum Kim
30-05-2026
The hot sopressata pie was good but it was really the vodka pie that blew me away. Their crust is definitely something special. Caesar salad was also a standout of the meal. Wonderful service. Came with friends on a Friday evening and it … More
Kraig DeMatteis
30-05-2026
Picked-up dinner but I want to come back to eat-in. Their bar counter overlooks their wide selection of bourbons and whiskeys in a cozy wood-covered interior. I did not order dinner myself but apparently you need to reserve spots for … More
Scott Miranda
30-05-2026
My son is GF so he ate before I did here. Came just after 5 so the dining area was packed!
But... they allowed me, my son, and my daughter to enjoy dinner at the bar. You guys were awesome and entertaining while my kids poked at the salad and stole the cherry from my Manhattan lol.
Arugula salad was nice and the Pizza, even better! Added onion and mushrooms to the Bay Ridge that I ordered and tried with the spicy crunch added.
Gave great recommendations and we're really attentive. Thank you for this great meal!
I'll be back when I can!
Price per person
$50–60
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reviews Wheated